There is a grave danger threatening world missions and the health of the church worldwide. It is the danger of American church planting groups infiltrating foreign fields.
Though it's as old as the apostles, "church planting" is a popular buzz in American Christianity, like an old fad rediscovered. My pastor
Dr. Bud Calvert, who has been harping on church planting for decades, told me recently how he is aware of this heightened buzz, but disappointed in its non-global focus.
Ed Stetzer
recently wrote about the emergence of church planting networks and also noted the exclusively local focus, saying:
Since some of those networks … are non-denominational, they often
do not have a global "arm" with which to cooperate for international
missions. So, it is often easier to just say, "well, we are just
planting here." But, I say you are missing out on God's global mission. So, I am encouraged when I see some groups take initial steps toward
global mission engagement.
So far, so good. I like hearing more about church planting in the USA. And I like hearing more about church planting globally. But what are those "initial steps towards global mission engagement"?
I know nothing of the groups Mr. Stetzer is associated with, so this is not a critique of his connections. But for two decades, I've observed how western para-church
organizations and church planters function in foreign fields. I've also had the chance to observe church planting operations in the United States.
Some church planting is thrilling—with growth by new conversions. This usually happens intentionally, when we aim for the lost and non-churched (we usually get what we aim for).
Most church planting,
however, is disappointing, with a seemingly intentional strategy of aiming for membership transplants by emphasizing internal
programs over outreach, aquarium decor over fishing for men. One pastor said, "If I had the best children's program and the best music program, I'd have the highest attendance of any church in the area." Some churches even have a marketing tagline that labels themselves "The Cure for the Common Church" (the
implication being that "our cool, new church is better than your dumb, old
church").
Please don't export that tripe to the foreign field. If you're going to do church planting globally, then go plant churches globally.
Find an unseeded field. Seek the lost. Plant the seed. And grow your
own work.
Ah, but that takes work. And time. And suffering. And learning languages. And navigating cultures. And risking failure. Winning new people to Christ and discipling them is harder than winning an already saved and committed Christian to your programs.
Do it anyway. Stop building upon another man's foundation (Romans 15:20).
One of our converts recently told me that in my field of service, a BIG name in American church planting has come in, not to learn the language and culture and win new converts, but to gather a group of believers to plant churches. They are each to seek out 5-10 families with which to plant new churches. My guy, ever discerning, said, "And where, pray tell, will you find those ten families? FROM OTHER CHURCHES!"
This is happening all the time on the foreign fields. I call it growth by theft.
Instead, please follow the
Biblical model for global Gospel engagement—don't look to the old American model, or to any of the many new American models, or even to models that are sweeping the East. Look to the Scriptures. You will discover that it will be hard to give a better definition of Scriptural missions than Peters gave in
A Biblical Theology of Missions. It is the most succinct and cogent formulation I have found:
Missions is the sending forth of authorized persons beyond
the borders of the New Testament church and her immediate gospel
influence to proclaim the gospel of Jesus Christ in Gospel-destitute
areas, to win converts from other faiths and non-faiths to Jesus Christ,
and to establish functioning, multiplying local congregations who will
bear the fruit of Christianity in that community and to that country.
So find a "Gospel-destitute area" and go do
that. That's a great "initial step towards global mission engagement." The call to missions is not to win converts from other Christian groups to your dazzling vision or to your niche of theologia. It is not a call to revitalize other
people's ministries with your fresh methodology. It
is not about expanding your network or
movement. It is to win converts from
other faiths and
non-faiths to Jesus Christ. Then train them up until your heart's content.
So many mission organizations and big shot pastors swoop down into a foreign culture like Big Business seeking mergers and acquisitions. Who can we tap into to promote our movement and publish our materials? Under the feigned humility of "working with the national leaders because they know the culture better" they use (and often pay) national leaders to expand their networks and push the missiological method
de jour. Then they return home with a nice batch of photos and boast of how many countries their network has reached and how many languages their materials are published into. A new flag goes up on the wall. A new nicknack displays on the bookshelf. More frequent flyer miles accrue. More missions money is spent.
And more indigenous movements are stifled.
They didn't mean to do it. They thought they were helping. Their intentions were as pure as they could be, perhaps. They didn't mean to destroy a movement with their money. But they imposed their vision and took
a short-cut to global missions engagement. They were sold on their program and so they sold the people on it, too. Over the short-term, it looked awesome. But over the long-haul, it merely gave some existing churches a facelift.
That's not missions.
I am not against all partnerships and training. But please don't go in to see how many churches you can integrate into your network. Go build your own network with people you win to Christ yourself (and by extension, with those that they win).
We are not called to seek ecclesiastical mergers, but rather to seek
the lost in places where the Gospel has not yet been proclaimed (Romans
15:20).